Believe it or not, the month matters. Car insurance isn’t a static thing; it’s seasonal, like pumpkin spice or tax refunds. For example, January and February are usually quiet. Not many people are thinking about switching insurance during the post-holiday hibernation.
Less demand means less competition for your attention. That’s a good thing for you. Compare it to shopping for swimsuits in July—everyone is looking, so prices stay high. Shop for a swimsuit in November? You get the clearance rack.
Similarly, late fall (October through early December) can be a stealthy sweet spot. People are busy with holidays, so insurance companies offer incentives to grab the few customers who are actually shopping. It’s the insurance version of a Black Friday deal, just without the crowds.